The Blue Jays Are Nearing Hard Conversations, But 2026 Contention Remains Possible

It’s only May, but the Toronto Blue Jays are already approaching a crossroads that could define their 2026 season. As of today, the reigning American League champs are sitting fourth in the AL East. Fresh off a commendable effort where their offense battled through a 10-inning grind, only to come up short in a 7-6 loss to the Tampa Bay. The Rays are currently the best team in the American League. The Jays and their fanbase have several reasons to feel deflated.

It’s a tale that surfaces around this time every season, and it afflicts a handful of clubs as the summer months approach. The Jays, Mets, Phillies, and Red Sox have done everything conceivably possible to avoid the burning question, but sooner or later, it becomes unavoidable.

Where To Go From Here?

At what point do teams truly start to realize contention is out of reach, and the option to become “sellers” starts to circulate? Which teams are moving closer to having these conversations?

These have undoubtedly become more complicated questions as the playoffs have expanded. Realistically, if 40% of teams make the playoffs, more clubs should remain around the cusp of contention. There are examples of teams barely squeezing into the playoffs via the wild card. Head-to-head tiebreakers during the regular season also come into play. Getting into the dance offers a tremendous opportunity for a club to go on a magical run.

Take the 2023 World Series, For Example:

The Texas Rangers secured a playoff berth by tying for the division lead but settling for a wild card spot, despite going just 4-9 against their interstate rival Astros. The Rangers cruised through the first two rounds before prevailing in a seven-game ALCS battle for the ages.

Texas overcame regular season adversity, and got hot at just the right time, capturing their first World Series in 2023

Conversely, the Arizona Diamondbacks, who had likely considered selling some of their higher-contract players to contenders, decided to take a more measured approach. Despite a June downward spiral that saw the D-Backs go 8-18, the front office resisted a sell-off. Instead, Arizona acquired Paul Sewald from Seattle.

Sewald proved durable and willing to take the ball in high-leverage moments down the stretch, filling an area of need that had previously been exposed. They also added Ryan Thompson, further transforming their bullpen from a possible weakness into a definite strength.

Another slide in August almost pushed the D-Backs out of contention again, but they didn’t panic. Arizona GM and President of Baseball Operations Mike Hazen, along with manager Torey Lovullo, saw a pathway forward. They knew the final wild card spot remained within reach.

The D-Backs posted a strong September run and ultimately earned the final spot with a modest 84-78 record. But they became scorching hot at just the right time, sweeping the Brewers and Dodgers before slugging their way past a stacked Phillies team in seven games en route to their first World Series appearance since winning it all in 2001.

Can the Blue Jays, Mets, Phillies Rally and Contend?

There are, of course, other examples of teams similar to the Rangers and D-Backs deciding to hold firm and perhaps fill a need around the trade deadline. Just last year, the Giants sat six games below .500 and decided to sell, only for their remaining core to rally within a couple games of capturing the final playoff spot.

The Reds, Marlins, and Guardians all battled through the final weekend of the season, keeping their fanbases engaged and intrigued, because history has shown that once a team enters the playoff bracket, virtually anything can happen.

The Blue Jays currently sit with a 20% chance of capturing an American League Wild Card spot. To be candid, they’ve made some rather peculiar moves lately.

They DFA’d left-handed pitcher Eric Lauer this week at a time when there are still questions surrounding a starting rotation afflicted by lingering injuries and IL stints. Lauer was integral in helping the Blue Jays toward a division title and a valiant playoff run in 2025.

The idea of him first being shuffled into mysterious roles, such as taking the ball from a reliever and being asked to shove through innings two through five. Following that, to then be publicly scrutinized for his inability to immediately adapt, was certainly a head-scratcher.

John Schneider was direct and rather cold in his rationale for DFA’ing Lauer.

“Just results. Tough conversation because of what he did last year. I know it was kind of back and forth with him this year, bullpen and starting. Just felt like we needed to go in a different direction. That's it. Those conversations suck. Baseball's hard. We get it. Hopefully, he can get back to the stuff being where it was last year,” said Schneider.

With Lauer gone, the rotation, which has already had to endure an anemic offense, is left with a tall order. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s disappointing two home runs and OPS slightly north of .700 only amplify those concerns.

Still, the front end of the rotation featuring Kevin Gausman, Dylan Cease, and Trey Yesavage has once again proven highly effective. They are, potentially the kind of warrior trio that could blaze through a playoff bracket and shut down any offense.

The Jays know this.

But without scoring runs, and with an inability to slug or consistently do offensive damage, the tenured contracts belonging to players like Springer and Gausman become increasingly vulnerable as the trade deadline approaches. Many teams would gladly welcome rental players like Springer or Gausman to help catapult playoff pushes late in the 2026 season.

Blue Jays Fans Show Full Support

Jays fans, who still pack Rogers Centre nightly with intent and optimism, are hoping it doesn’t come to that.

But even if it does, it doesn’t necessarily mean they’re out of it.

Keep the faith, Jays fans.

Follow the Blue Jays playoff chase Here